Energy trading analytics vs ETRM: what an analyst desk needs
Published , by a team that builds the analytics side and not the ETRM
An ETRM system (energy trading and risk management, or CTRM when it covers other commodities too) is a desk's book of record: it captures each deal, keeps and values the position, measures market and credit risk, schedules physical delivery, and settles and invoices the trade. An energy trading analytics workspace is where analysts read the market: fundamentals such as storage, flows, outages and imbalance, the values as they were first published, alerts, and the desk's own marks next to public series.
The two answer different questions. The ETRM answers what the desk holds and what it is worth; the analytics workspace answers what the market is doing and what the data said when the desk acted. Neither does the other's job, which is why many mid-tier gas and short-term power desks run both.
Voltstack is an analytics workspace, not an ETRM: it books no trades, values no positions and settles nothing. It reads official European gas and power sources, keeps many of their values with the time it read them, and lets a desk put its own marks beside them. The 14-day trial opens the workspace.
Start a 14-day free trialRequest early access →The button opens a 14-day free trial sign-up. Sign-up needs a work email.
The button opens the early-access request on our home page.
What an ETRM or CTRM system does
ETRM vendors describe their systems by the life of a trade, from capture to settlement. The jobs below belong to the category, not to any one product. Which of them a given system covers, and how well, is for its vendor to state and for you to test.
Deal capture
Every trade goes in once, with its counterparty, product, delivery period, volume and price, and the terms that matter later: delivery point, index, optionality. Trades done on a broker or exchange screen can arrive from the execution platform without being typed again.
Position and valuation
The system adds trades up into positions by commodity, delivery period and location, and values them against forward curves that it imports from the desk's licensed price sources. This is the mark-to-market the middle office signs off.
Risk and credit
Market risk measures and limits on the book, and credit exposure to each counterparty against the limits the firm sets.
Scheduling and logistics
Physical trades need nominations to pipeline and storage operators and schedules to grid operators. On a gas desk this includes transport and storage contracts; on a power desk, the schedules that decide imbalance exposure.
Settlement and invoicing
After delivery, trades are confirmed, reconciled against what actually flowed, invoiced or self-billed, and passed to accounting. Reporting trades to regulators, where the firm must, usually draws on the same record.
What an energy trading analytics workspace does
Fundamentals
The public data that moves gas and power: storage stocks and withdrawals, pipeline flows, LNG send-out, generation outages, imbalance prices, cross-border flows, load and renewables forecasts, hydro reservoirs. Each publisher has its own format, time zone and gas-day convention. The workspace reads them into one place and names the source on each series.
The as-published record
Many public series are corrected after first publication, and the publisher usually shows only the latest value. A workspace that keeps each value with the time it read it can show what a series said when the desk acted, which matters for a backtest and for explaining a morning call after the fact. Our guide to point-in-time data counts how often this happens, series by series.
Alerts
A rule on a series, such as storage fill falling below a level or an outage on a named unit, that tells the analyst when it trips, so the morning check does not depend on someone opening the right chart.
Desk marks next to public series
The desk's own numbers (its marks, its forecasts, its view of a spread) shown beside the public fundamentals and kept private to the desk. This is analysis, not valuation: the marks that value the book still live in the ETRM.
What an analytics workspace does not do is hold the book. No trade is captured, no position is valued for the accounts, and nothing is scheduled, confirmed or invoiced.
ETRM and analytics workspace, job by job
| Job | ETRM or CTRM | Analytics workspace |
|---|---|---|
| Book of record for trades | Yes: its core job | No |
| Positions and mark-to-market valuation | Yes, against forward curves imported from licensed price sources | No. It may show a desk's own marks for analysis, not for the accounts |
| Market risk and credit exposure on the book | Yes | No |
| Nominations and scheduling of physical delivery | Yes, for physical trades | No |
| Confirmation, settlement and invoicing | Yes | No |
| Public fundamentals: storage, flows, LNG, outages, imbalance | Not its focus. It consumes prices and curves to value the book | Yes: its core job |
| Values as first published, kept with the time they were read | Not its job | Yes, where the workspace records them. Check the start date for each series |
| Alerts | On the book: limits and exposures | On the market: a rule on a public series |
| The desk's own numbers | The official marks, for valuation | The analyst's marks and forecasts, beside public series, for analysis |
| Who works in it each day | Front, middle and back office, operations, finance | Analysts and traders |
| How it is usually bought | As a project, because it touches confirmations, accounting and operations | Through a trial on public data first; confidential desk data brings a security review |
The table describes the two categories, not any product. Products differ, so test the jobs you need.
Where each fits for a gas or short-term power desk
By mid-tier we mean a utility's trading arm, an independent trading house or a fund desk with a few analysts and no platform team building its own data stack.
A gas desk
The ETRM carries the deals, the transport and storage contracts, the daily nominations and the invoices. The analyst's day starts elsewhere: EU and national storage (days of gas), Norwegian flows and maintenance (Norway gas flows), LNG send-out by terminal (LNG send-out), and whether yesterday's numbers have since been corrected. Those are analytics jobs.
A short-term power desk
Day-ahead and intraday trades, schedules to the grid operator and imbalance settlement sit in the ETRM or in a scheduling system beside it. The analyst watches unit outages, cross-border flows, load and renewables forecasts and imbalance prices, which grid operators correct after first publication. Our ENTSO-E API guide shows where most of those series come from.
Why many desks run both
The two meet at the price curve and the trade. The ETRM needs curves to value the book and takes them from licensed price sources; the analytics workspace explains why the market moved and what the fundamentals said at the time. When one is stretched to do the other's job, the usual result is spreadsheets: analysts rebuild fundamentals around the ETRM, or someone keeps a book around a research tool.
Questions to ask before you buy either
- Is the gap in recording and settling trades, or in understanding the market? The first is an ETRM question.
- For each public series you rely on, can the tool show what it said at a past moment, and from what date?
- Where do the forward curves come from, and under whose licence?
- Will confidential desk data leave your systems? If so, plan for a security review before the trial ends.
What Voltstack is, and what it is not
Voltstack is an analytics workspace. It is not an ETRM or a CTRM: it captures no deals, values no positions, runs no risk on a book, schedules nothing, and settles or invoices nothing. It holds no licensed exchange prices or forward curves; those reach a desk under its own licence.
- It reads official European gas and power sources, among them GIE, ENTSOG, ENTSO-E, Gassco, NVE, Elexon and NESO, and names the source on each series.
- It keeps values with the time it read them: outage filings since 14 Jul 2026, and imbalance prices, cross-border flows, EU gas storage and LNG send-out since 23 Sep 2026. That history builds forward from those dates and is not backfilled.
- It sends alerts on server-evaluated series by email.
- A desk can load its own marks and series by CSV, private to its workspace.
Two parts are not generally available. The Voltstack API is in early access, with keys issued on request. The Revision Record, a morning note of overnight changes to public series, is a pilot that a desk requests by writing to research@voltstack.energy.
Examples of ETRM and trading software, in their own words
These names come up when you search for ETRM or energy trading software. They are examples of the category, not a ranking or a recommendation, and Voltstack is not affiliated with any of them. Each line says only what the vendor states on its own site, read on 10 Nov 2026. Features, prices and quality are for each vendor to state and for you to check.
| Vendor | What its own site says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Hitachi Energy | Describes its ETRM software solution as front-to-back-office and covering the commodity life cycle "from trade capture and position management to scheduling, risk analysis, and settlement". | hitachienergy.com, ETRM software solution page |
| Energy One | Says its enTrader product "supports the full trade lifecycle from deal capture and risk management through to settlement processes". The same page lists its ETRM products for other regions. | energyone.com, ETRM solutions page |
| Brady Technologies | Describes Brady ETRM as a European energy trading and risk management platform with "front, mid, and back-office functionality". | bradytechnologies.com, Brady ETRM page |
| CGI | Describes "an all-inclusive approach to Energy Trading & Risk Management" that adds user-defined functionality over the life of a system. | cgi.com, ETRM brochure page |
| Trayport | Says it "is a software provider of trading solutions and is not a trading venue", and that its API connects "to downstream ETRM software for straight-through-processing". | trayport.com, Joule product page and North America page |
Brady's own explainer of 26 Apr 2024 draws the same line between execution platforms and ETRM systems: trading platforms, it says, typically do not cover risk management or back-office functions.
ETRM and analytics questions
What is an ETRM system?
What is the difference between ETRM and CTRM?
Can an energy trading analytics platform replace an ETRM?
Is Trayport an ETRM?
Why do trading desks run both an ETRM and an analytics tool?
Is Voltstack an ETRM?
Read the market beside the system that keeps your book
The 14-day trial opens the Voltstack workspace with public European gas and power series in it, each named by its source. Nothing in it books, values or settles a trade.
The button opens a 14-day free trial sign-up. Sign-up needs a work email.
The button opens the early-access request on our home page.
More for analyst desks
Sources: each vendor's own pages, read on 10 Nov 2026: https://www.hitachienergy.com/products-and-solutions/energy-portfolio-management/energy-commercial-enablement-software-solutions/energy-trading-and-risk-management-etrm-software-solution; https://www.energyone.com/etrm-commodities-trading-settlements-and-risk/; https://www.bradytechnologies.com/brady-etrm/; https://www.cgi.com/uk/en-gb/brochure/energy-utilities/energy-trading-risk-management-etrm; https://trayport.com/products/joule/; https://trayport.com/regions/north-america/; and Brady Technologies, "Energy trading platform vs ETRM system", 26 Apr 2024 (https://www.bradytechnologies.com/news/energy-trading-platform-vs-etrm-system/). Voltstack's capture start dates are those its own coverage record gives. This page prints no price from any exchange or vendor.
Disclaimer: Produced by Voltstack Intelligence for information only. Product names and trademarks belong to their owners. If a line about a vendor is wrong, write to research@voltstack.energy and we will correct it.