On the 12 November closes, France's gas hub sat about €1.30/MWh under TTF for February and March 2027, roughly twice the discount the last three winters delivered. Behind that price, Norwegian gas has left Dunkerque, French storage is being drawn faster than in any year since at least 2011 for the date, and imports under long-term Russian LNG contracts are banned from 1 January. We expect the February and March discount to narrow.
Storage: GIE AGSI+ (Gas Infrastructure Europe, https://agsi.gie.eu/). Nomination: Gassco (umm.gassco.no). Dunkerque and France to Belgium: ENTSOG TP 17-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/. Totals, sums, averages, ranges and comparisons shown are Voltstack calculations from ENTSOG TP data, not ENTSOG figures, and ENTSOG does not endorse them. Storage draw: Voltstack's calculation from ENTSOG storage flows, ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/, and the operators' daily stock, Storengy, Teréga, Stock quotidien dans les stockages de gaz (à partir de novembre 2010), odre.opendatasoft.com, Licence Ouverte v2.0, updated 20 Oct 2026. Q1 history of PEG minus TTF: our arithmetic on NaTran, Smart, PEG daily average price series (the weighted average of each gas day's PEG trades), smart.natrangroupe.com, read 11 Nov 2026, less EEX's TTF spot monthly average.
Four reads refresh at least every six hours, and each live figure carries its gas day: France's storage fill against its five-year band (GIE AGSI+), Gassco's nominations by exit against their five-year bands, Norwegian gas landing at Dunkerque, and France's net flow to Belgium at Virtualys (both ENTSOG). Everything else is dated copy from our research of 11 to 13 November 2026. Prices are the closes of 12 November unless a row says otherwise, and the French balance runs to gas day 11 November, the newest the operators had published. When a live read fails, its figure is withheld and marked as not read; the dated figure in the text stands.
On the 12 November closes PEG sat 1.58 under TTF for December and between 1.11 and 1.31 under for each of January, February and March. In the last three first quarters the discount averaged between 0.5 and 0.8 (NaTran, Smart, PEG daily average price series (the weighted average of each gas day's PEG trades), smart.natrangroupe.com, read 11 Nov 2026).
The physical position behind that price is weaker than the price says. Norwegian gas has left Dunkerque. French storage is covering the gap at the fastest rate for the date since at least 2011, from a stock that was already low. From 1 January imports under long-term Russian LNG contracts are banned, and France took more Yamal LNG than any other EU country in the first half of 2026. Every route by which France gets through February and March needs PEG to stop being the cheapest hub in the north-west: Norway routing back, more LNG, or exports to Belgium stopping.
So we expect the forward discount for February and March to narrow, to its usual size at least, and to parity if France has to stop exporting.
A spread between two hubs. It takes no view on the outright price of gas or on the Strait of Hormuz, and it does not say France runs out of gas. Section 08 sets out the case against it and section 09 the rules for dropping it.
| Tenor | PEG, 12 Nov | TTF, 12 Nov | PEG minus TTF, 12 Nov | PEG minus TTF, 10 Nov |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec-26 | 90.68 | 92.26 | -1.58 | -1.68 |
| Jan-27 | 90.97 | 92.08 | -1.11 | -1.24 |
| Feb-27 | 90.15 | 91.41 | -1.26 | -1.29 |
| Mar-27 | 86.81 | 88.12 | -1.31 | -1.26 |
| Q1-27 | 89.28 | 90.51 | -1.23 | -1.26 |
EUR/MWh, closes of 12 and 10 November 2026. PEG: EEX settlements as republished by Kelwatt and Selectra. TTF: ICE Endex closes from the Elexys forward table, which carries no date; the date rests on Yahoo Finance's TTF futures closes matching it to the cent on 10, 11 and 12 November. The legs come from two exchanges, so the spread carries a small settlement-window difference. Both legs rose about 7.5 between the two dates and we found no report explaining the move; the spread barely changed. Quoted, not charted.
For scale, the first-quarter average of PEG minus TTF was -0.78 in 2024, -0.53 in 2025 and -0.47 in 2026, and single months in those quarters ran from 1.88 under (February 2026) to 0.68 over (March 2026). Those are our arithmetic on two different price definitions: NaTran's published PEG gas-day average (NaTran, Smart, PEG daily average price series (the weighted average of each gas day's PEG trades), smart.natrangroupe.com, read 11 Nov 2026) less EEX's TTF spot monthly average. The forward has sat between 0.9 and 1.7 under on every date we looked at. TotalEnergies' weekly market notes put Q1-27 at 0.87 under on the 19 October close and 0.88 under on 2 November, so only about 0.3 to 0.4 of today's discount is new.
Since 2022 gas has mostly flowed out of France, into Belgium and on toward Germany, and into Switzerland. A hub that exports trades under the hub it exports to, by roughly what it costs to move the gas. That is our reading of the discount, and the flow has not always run this way. Before 2021 gas ran from Belgium into France as a rule: 289 to 355 GWh a day in the same fortnight of 2016 to 2018 (ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/ (TP Archives, calendar years 2016 to 2020); Totals, sums, averages, ranges and comparisons shown are Voltstack calculations from ENTSOG TP data, not ENTSOG figures, and ENTSOG does not endorse them.) In ENTSOG's series from 1 Oct 2021, the net flow at Virtualys has run into France on 272 gas days, and the highest day out of France is 318.9 GWh/d on 9 Nov 2026, ahead of 309.6 on 8 Nov 2026 (provisional; LIVE, ENTSOG TP 17-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/).
Over 3 Nov to 16 Nov 2026 France sent Belgium 290 GWh a day net, against 164 on the same dates a year earlier and 238 in 2024, 266 in 2023, 223 in 2022, 76 in 2021 (LIVE, ENTSOG TP 17-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/).
If France had to import from Belgium instead, PEG would need to sit above TTF by roughly the cost of bringing gas in. Firm entry into France at Virtualys costs about 0.50 per MWh for a first-quarter product on NaTran's tariff (CRE, ATRT8), before Belgium's exit charge, which we have not confirmed.
Norwegian gas landing at Dunkerque averaged 145 GWh a day over 3 Nov to 16 Nov 2026, against 513 on the same dates a year earlier, and 106 on 16 Nov 2026, the newest gas day published (provisional; LIVE, ENTSOG TP 17-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/).
On the fortnight to 10 November, ENTSOG's data have 2026 as the lowest of eleven years: 264 GWh a day, against 436 to 560 in 2016 to 2023, 355 in 2024 and 524 in 2025 (ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/ (TP Archives, calendar years 2016 to 2020) for 2016 to 2020, ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/ from 2021; Totals, sums, averages, ranges and comparisons shown are Voltstack calculations from ENTSOG TP data, not ENTSOG figures, and ENTSOG does not endorse them.) The fall began about 21 October and steepened on 31 October, before the Visund fire of 4 November. Norway's total did not fall with it. The gas went to Britain, where landings were up 209 GWh a day on the year over 27 October to 10 November, and to Germany, up 54 (ENTSOG, read 11 November; ENTSOG TP 11-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/; Totals, sums, averages, ranges and comparisons shown are Voltstack calculations from ENTSOG TP data, not ENTSOG figures, and ENTSOG does not endorse them.)
Gassco's nominations for gas day 17 Nov 2026 show where Norwegian gas is going: 324.6 MSm³/d in all, against a five-year median of 335.9 for the date, with Dunkerque at 10.0, below the five-year low (LIVE).
| Exit | Route | Nominated | Band low | Band median | Band high | Years | Position |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dunkerque | France | 10.0 | 15.0 | 45.5 | 53.2 | 5 | below the five-year low |
| Easington | Britain | 68.7 | 33.7 | 71.6 | 75.1 | 5 | below the five-year median |
| St Fergus | Britain | 25.2 | 0.4 | 4.3 | 27.3 | 5 | above the five-year median |
| Fields into SEGAL | Britain | 14.9 | 7.0 | 14.5 | 22.7 | 5 | above the five-year median |
| Dornum | Germany | 67.4 | 27.2 | 52.4 | 66.0 | 5 | above the five-year high |
| Emden | Germany | 74.0 | 59.5 | 87.2 | 91.6 | 5 | below the five-year median |
| Zeebrugge | Belgium | 44.4 | 36.9 | 42.7 | 44.4 | 5 | above the five-year median |
| Nybro | Denmark and Poland | 17.7 | 6.1 | 24.1 | 29.2 | 4 | below the four-year median |
| All exits | Total | 324.6 | 282.0 | 335.9 | 359.1 | 5 | below the five-year median |
MSm³/d for gas day 17 Nov 2026, LIVE. Bands are the platform's: the nominations for the same date, plus or minus seven days, over the previous five years, or over as many years as the platform holds for an exit (the Years column). Source: Gassco (umm.gassco.no).
When we read Gassco's message feed on 13 November it carried an unplanned Troll outage of 11.3 MSm³/d running to about 16 November, and no notice naming Dunkerque or Franpipe.
France drew a net 735 GWh a day from storage over 29 October to 11 November 2026. For those dates the next highest years since 2011 are 528 (2021), 452 (2012) and 333 (2016). The daily draw reached 1,180 GWh on 5 November and has eased since, to 651 on 11 November. The stock on 11 November, 98.3 TWh, was under 2017's for the date and otherwise the lowest since at least 2011. These figures are Voltstack's calculation from ENTSOG storage flows, ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/, and the operators' daily stock, Storengy, Teréga, Stock quotidien dans les stockages de gaz (à partir de novembre 2010), odre.opendatasoft.com, Licence Ouverte v2.0, updated 20 Oct 2026. Totals, sums, averages, ranges and comparisons shown are Voltstack calculations from ENTSOG TP data, not ENTSOG figures, and ENTSOG does not endorse them. The newest days are provisional.
On AGSI+ France was 76.5% full on gas day 15 Nov 2026, 10.0 points under the five-year low for the date (86.5%) and 17.2 under the five-year average; fourteen days earlier it was 86.4%. Germany was 57.1% full on gas day 17 Nov 2026 (LIVE).
Suppliers had to fill 85% of their booked capacity by 1 November. No French rule we found keeps gas in store after that test, so from 2 November shippers could draw freely.
Regulation (EU) 2026/261 bans imports of Russian LNG under long-term contracts from 1 January 2027 (the Council's final adopted text, PE-CONS 63/25). France took 3.74 Mt of the 9.97 Mt of Yamal LNG landed in the EU in January to June 2026, more than any other member state (Urgewald, with Kpler tracking), which is about 310 GWh a day. IEEFA put Russia at about 35% of French LNG imports in the first quarter; we have not verified that share. TotalEnergies' chief executive said on 29 October that the company would likely take about 3 Mt a year from Yamal from January, with destinations set by distance and freight (Interfax). As of 13 November we had found no public plan to supply Dunkerque LNG and Montoir in the first quarter.
Over 29 October to 11 November France drew 735 GWh a day from storage, where a year earlier it injected 48: a swing of about 782 GWh a day. It splits like this.
| Driver | Share | GWh/d | 2026 against 2025, same dates |
|---|---|---|---|
| Norwegian gas not arriving at Dunkerque | 36% | 282 | 242 against 524 GWh/d |
| Gas burned for power | 27% | 213 | 246 against 33 GWh/d at NaTran's combined-cycle gas plants |
| Lower LNG send-out | 13% | 105 | 839 against 944 GWh/d |
| Heating and industry | 13% | 103 | distribution networks 756 against 629 GWh/d; other industry 294 against 318 |
| Net exports | 11% | 87 | Belgium 295 against 186 GWh/d; Switzerland 222 against 245 |
| Spain, L-gas, production and residual | -1% | -8 |
29 October to 11 November 2026 against the same dates of 2025. Voltstack's calculation from ENTSOG flows, ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/, and NaTran, Consommation quotidienne de gaz des Centrales à Cycle Combiné Gaz, odre.opendatasoft.com, Licence Ouverte v2.0, updated 13 Nov 2026. Totals, sums, averages, ranges and comparisons shown are Voltstack calculations from ENTSOG TP data, not ENTSOG figures, and ENTSOG does not endorse them. The flows close to within about 15 GWh a day. Against 2024 the swing is 494 GWh/d, heating and industry and LNG lead it, and exports are about a fifth (97 of 494).
France is burning most of the extra gas at home. Exports are the one part of the draw it could switch off, and they are about a tenth of it.
| Mean GW, 29 Oct to 11 Nov | 2026 | 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Nuclear | 41.4 | 44.3 |
| Hydro | 4.7 | 7.3 |
| Wind | 4.8 | 7.8 |
| Solar | 2.8 | 2.4 |
| Demand | 53.2 | 49.2 |
| Net exports | 6.6 | 14.2 |
| Gas | 5.5 | 1.4 |
RTE, éCO2mix national data, odre.opendatasoft.com, Licence Ouverte v2.0: the real-time series (2026) as updated on 13 Nov 2026 and the consolidated series (2025) updated 6 Oct 2026. The 2026 figures are provisional; quarter hours in UTC. Quoted, not charted.
There is no single cause. Supply from everything except gas was about 8 GW lower and demand about 4 GW higher. France cut its power exports by about 8 GW, which left gas plants running about 4 GW harder.
| Fill | Available withdrawal, GWh/d |
|---|---|
| 80% | 2,261 |
| 60% | 2,108 |
| 40% | 1,832 |
| 30% | 1,547 |
| 20% | 1,262 |
| 10% | 902 |
France's curve in the Voltstack deliverability index: the withdrawal curves (provided by GSE) in Annex A of ENTSOG's Summer Supply Outlook 2026, published 9 April 2026, the mean of France's five storage areas, applied to the technical maximum AGSI+ declares for France, 2,415 GWh/d.
NaTran and Teréga's winter outlook for 2026-27 gives 1,954 GWh a day at 45% full and 1,309 at 20%. French peak days in the last five winters ran 1,490 to 1,986 GWh a day of withdrawal. The highest daily offtake in those winters was 2,674 GWh on 12 December 2022. On a day like that storage would need to supply about 680 if LNG and Norway ran at their past maxima and exports to Belgium stopped, and about 2,100 on the flows of early November (ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/; Totals, sums, averages, ranges and comparisons shown are Voltstack calculations from ENTSOG TP data, not ENTSOG figures, and ENTSOG does not endorse them.)
The winter of 2017/18 began at 101.3 TWh on 1 November and ended at 3.9 TWh on 31 March, after a late-February cold spell in which France drew 1,306 GWh a day at 15.8% full (Storengy, Teréga, Stock quotidien dans les stockages de gaz (à partir de novembre 2010), odre.opendatasoft.com, Licence Ouverte v2.0, updated 20 Oct 2026). In the same fortnight of 2017 France was a net importer of about 620 GWh a day across its Belgian, German and Swiss borders. In the fortnight to 10 November 2026 it was a net exporter of about 520 (Belgium 296, Switzerland 221; ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/ (TP Archives, calendar years 2016 to 2020) for 2017, ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/ for 2026; Totals, sums, averages, ranges and comparisons shown are Voltstack calculations from ENTSOG TP data, not ENTSOG figures, and ENTSOG does not endorse them.) One winter proves little, and our eleven-winters note found that an autumn reading of the deliverability index says little about the March trough until December. The 2017 comparison is here for the direction of the flows.
| Scenario | The stock | The spread |
|---|---|---|
| The present Norway and export flows persist | Replaying the four winters since 2022 from the 11 November stock with Dunkerque at 242 GWh/d (ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/), the first day the need exceeds what storage delivers falls between the first week of January and early February. | Cannot last, so it closes early. |
| Norway returns to last year's level, or exports to Belgium stop | On the four post-2022 replays from the 11 November stock, storage comes up short in one winter, and only in March (Voltstack's calculation from ENTSOG storage flows, ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/, and the operators' daily stock, Storengy, Teréga, Stock quotidien dans les stockages de gaz (à partir de novembre 2010), odre.opendatasoft.com, Licence Ouverte v2.0, updated 20 Oct 2026. Totals, sums, averages, ranges and comparisons shown are Voltstack calculations from ENTSOG TP data, not ENTSOG figures, and ENTSOG does not endorse them.) | This is the spread closing: neither happens while PEG is the cheapest hub. |
| Russian LNG lost from 1 January and not replaced (310 GWh/d) | On all 15 winters' draws from the 11 November stock: 40% full in mid-January, 30% late in January, 20% early in February. The need exceeds what storage delivers in all 15, from the third week of January at the median (Voltstack's calculation from ENTSOG storage flows, ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/, and the operators' daily stock, Storengy, Teréga, Stock quotidien dans les stockages de gaz (à partir de novembre 2010), odre.opendatasoft.com, Licence Ouverte v2.0, updated 20 Oct 2026. Totals, sums, averages, ranges and comparisons shown are Voltstack calculations from ENTSOG TP data, not ENTSOG figures, and ENTSOG does not endorse them.) | Closes, with spike days possible. |
| Russian LNG replaced by other cargoes | French terminals sent out 843 GWh/d in the fortnight to 10 November against a best winter day near 1,370, so over 500 GWh/d of regasification is spare (ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/; Totals, sums, averages, ranges and comparisons shown are Voltstack calculations from ENTSOG TP data, not ENTSOG figures, and ENTSOG does not endorse them.) | The discount can last. |
| Mild winter, and nuclear back as filed | Gas burn for power falls back and the draw slows. | The discount can last, and the position loses a few tenths. |
The replays apply each past winter's real daily draw to the stated stock, cap each day at what the French curve can deliver, and ignore any price response. A shortfall in them is gas that has to come from somewhere other than French storage (more LNG, fewer exports, less burn). None of them is a forecast of a shortage. Dunkerque's 242 GWh/d is its 29 October to 11 November mean: Totals, sums, averages, ranges and comparisons shown are Voltstack calculations from ENTSOG TP data, not ENTSOG figures, and ENTSOG does not endorse them. The replays are Voltstack's calculation from ENTSOG storage flows, ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/, and the operators' daily stock, Storengy, Teréga, Stock quotidien dans les stockages de gaz (à partir de novembre 2010), odre.opendatasoft.com, Licence Ouverte v2.0, updated 20 Oct 2026.
Dunkerque nominated back above 40 MSm³/d, about 430 GWh/d, with PEG still more than a euro under TTF. That would mean Norway's routing had little to do with price. This is the exit rule first stated on 11 November. Gassco nominated 10.0 for gas day 17 Nov 2026 (LIVE).
Replacement cargoes booked into Dunkerque LNG and Montoir for the first quarter.
French gas burn for power, measured as NaTran's CCGT consumption on ODRE, back under about 50 GWh/d, with nuclear restarts arriving as filed.
New legislation delaying the ban. The regulation's own suspension clause is narrow: after a declared emergency the Commission may suspend it for at most four weeks at a time, and only short-term supply contracts may be imported under a suspension.
The spread reaching parity, at which point the view has paid.
This note does not size the position. The widest single month in the last three first quarters was 1.88 under (February 2026) and the narrowest 0.68 over (March 2026; NaTran, Smart, PEG daily average price series (the weighted average of each gas day's PEG trades), smart.natrangroupe.com, read 11 Nov 2026). We found no sourced figure for PEG against TTF in the February 2018 squeeze, so there is no measured stress case.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 26 and 27 Nov 2026 | Dec-26 TTF options and futures expire |
| 1 Dec | End of the window in which the EU storage fill target is met |
| December | Nuclear restarts filed for December are due |
| 30 Dec | Jan-27 TTF futures expire |
| 1 Jan 2027 | Imports under long-term Russian LNG contracts banned; an EU ban on services to LNG tankers serving Russia is reported for the same date |
| 13 to 21 Jan | France 40% full on past winters' draws from the 11 November stock |
| About 18 Jan | Germany crosses 30% on the median of past winters' draws (as read on 11 November) |
| 24 to 31 Jan | France 30% full on past winters' draws |
| 28 Jan | Feb-27 TTF futures expire |
| 1 Feb | Germany's 30% fill test |
| Early Feb | The middle date on which French need exceeds what storage delivers, in 10 of 15 winters |
| 25 Feb | Mar-27 TTF futures expire |
| 31 Mar | Germany's fill-level rules lapse |
Since 2022 gas has mostly flowed out of France into Belgium and Switzerland, and a hub that exports trades under the hub it exports to by roughly what it costs to move the gas. On the 12 November 2026 closes PEG sat 1.26 under TTF for February 2027 and 1.31 under for March, against first-quarter averages of 0.78, 0.53 and 0.47 under in 2024, 2025 and 2026 (our arithmetic on NaTran, Smart, PEG daily average price series (the weighted average of each gas day's PEG trades), smart.natrangroupe.com, read 11 Nov 2026, less EEX's TTF spot monthly average). Before 2021 gas ran from Belgium into France as a rule.
Over 29 October to 11 November 2026 France drew a net 735 GWh a day from storage, the most for those dates since at least 2011. Against the same dates of 2025, missing Norwegian gas at Dunkerque explains about 36% of the extra draw, gas burned for power 27%, LNG and heating and industry about 13% each, and exports 11%. The draw is Voltstack's calculation from ENTSOG storage flows, ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/, and the operators' daily stock, Storengy, Teréga, Stock quotidien dans les stockages de gaz (à partir de novembre 2010), odre.opendatasoft.com, Licence Ouverte v2.0, updated 20 Oct 2026. The split is Voltstack's calculation from ENTSOG flows, ENTSOG TP 13-11-2026 https://transparency.entsog.eu/, and NaTran, Consommation quotidienne de gaz des Centrales à Cycle Combiné Gaz, odre.opendatasoft.com, Licence Ouverte v2.0, updated 13 Nov 2026. Totals, sums, averages, ranges and comparisons shown are Voltstack calculations from ENTSOG TP data, not ENTSOG figures, and ENTSOG does not endorse them.
Dunkerque nominated back above 40 MSm3/d, about 430 GWh/d, while PEG stays more than a euro under TTF; replacement cargoes booked into Dunkerque LNG and Montoir for the first quarter; French gas burn for power, measured as NaTran's CCGT consumption on ODRE, back under about 50 GWh/d with nuclear restarts arriving as filed; or new legislation delaying the 1 January 2027 ban on Russian LNG under long-term contracts. The spread reaching parity means the view has paid.
AGSI+ and ALSI+ live · Gassco nominations and outages · ENTSOG flows · Storage deliverability index · Spread monitors with your own marks
voltstack.energy